Illustrator: Glenn Harvey

The fast money on Wall Street has taken a close look at key sectors in the green economy and decided to bet against them.

Despite vast green stimulus packages in the US, Europe and China, more hedge funds are on average net short batteries, solar, electric vehicles and hydrogen than are long those sectors; and more funds are net long fossil fuels than are shorting oil, gas and coal, according to a Bloomberg News analysis of positions voluntarily disclosed by roughly 500 hedge funds to Hazeltree, a data compiler in the alternative investment industry.

The findings provide a glimpse of how the most rarefied corner of finance has cooled on the investment prospects of a green transition that scientists, along with many policymakers as well as company executives and economists, argue is critical to avoid the most devastating impacts from global warming.

Listen and follow The Big Take on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts

Managers in the $5 trillion hedge fund industry say the reason is obvious: Despite the promises, clean energy and green technology stocks have lagged far behind the broader market. Deep-pocketed institutions are concluding that many climate investments won’t pay off as quickly, or as lucratively, as they’d hoped.

The Bloomberg analysis reveals the preferences of an investor class known for trying to conduct its business outside the glare of public scrutiny.

Hedge Funds are Largely Short on Green Stocks

A modest group within the 500+ hedge funds invest in the energy sector, but their positions show caution around green stocks and confidence in fossil fuels

Percentage of hedge funds with net long

or net short

positions, monthly average

SOLAR

BATTERIES

ELECTRIC VEHICLES

HYDROGEN

4%

4%