There’s “just too many early stage companies going public”, or so goes one of the most common lamentations about the current state of the biotech market.

I’ve read a good deal of venting covering this theme, including comments about VCs pushing low quality junk into the market, or others saying insiders should be locked up until a biotech’s first drug gets approved by the FDA. Much of this venting misses the mark, and in my opinion throws the baby out with the bathwater.

An open and permissive IPO market, and the flow of capital that enables it, has been a huge positive for the sector and for advancing innovation, and is not what caused the current market pullback.

As discussed in an earlier blogpost, a significant driver of the malaise in the markets has been the overall risk-off sentiment favoring value over growth, driving stocks in the innovation sector downward since Feb 2021, in particular as generalist funds moved elsewhere.

With that backdrop, there are, of course, a number of biotech-related issues, including the declining ratio of positive-to-negative newsflow in the sector as a whole, especially for clinical and FDA/regulatory events. Our sector’s woes been exacerbated by a lack of M&A by larger players in the ecosystem, which normally recycles capital, talent, and ideas.

But overall, I think it’s a mistake to blame “too many early stage IPOs” for the plight of the markets today.

First let’s start with a little data, courtesy of the monthly IPO dataset from BMO Capital. Looking at 157 therapeutic biotech IPOs that went public in 2020 thru early January 2022, if you bucket them by stage of lead asset, there were 27% preclinical, 32% in Phase 1, 27% in Phase 2, and 14% Phase 3 or later. The after-market performance is captured in the chart below, as of March 21, 2022, with medians and quartiles. As is evident, the returns (losses) of these four groups of IPOs don’t track with stage. If it was true that the preclinical IPOs, the earliest of early stage, were the bigger cause of this market’s issues, you wouldn’t see this – you’d see a trendline towards “better” relative returns in later stage assets. That’s not really been the case.

While all these returns are horrible (and they are), they aren’t that far out of line with the rest of the market: the overall biotech market ($XBI) has delivered -47% since peaking in Feb 2021, while the average returns of this group are -37% from their IPOs in 2020-2022. Further, these data provide a counterpoint to the concept that early stage, preclinical IPOs are the culprit for dragging down the overall market. This also reinforces that IPO quality (caveat: if 1-2 year returns are actually proxy for quality) isn’t necessarily stage-dependent, but integrates a number of other factors related the science, team, and potential impact.

Given the debate about “too many” early biotech IPOs, I do think it’s worth reflecting more generally on the state of the biotech IPO markets and how we see the process as venture creation company-builders – so here’s a small treatise on the subject.

Stepping back for context, the biotech IPO market really began changing in late 2012, aided by the JOBS Act. We’re coming up on the 10-year anniversary of its signing on April 5, 2012 by President Obama. I’ve covered the IPO evolution in this blog before; in short, the “new” IPO process facilitated more fluid price discovery for private companies, whose end result was essentially an ever-open window, transforming the biotech sector from punctuated feast-or-famine cyclicality to a continuous conveyor-belt of access to scalable capital.

Today there isn’t a bright red line demarking “public” vs “private” biotech. It’s just a transition point from a relatively small capital pool (think puddle) to a larger capital pool (think ocean), with a commensurate increase in the number of shareholders. The “equity capital markets” start from when we do a seed round and continue through follow-on public equity financings done before a company hits profitability many years later. Different investors specialize at different phases, but for a company it’s not some sudden metamorphosis of a private caterpillar into a public butterfly. Instead, it’s a continuum of progression. The crossover phenom that emerged in 2012-2013 and accelerated recently has been a big driver of erasing whatever bright line there may have been between pre- and post-IPO biotechs in prior eras.

At Atlas, we start companies around what we believe is great science, finance them privately, take them public to access more capital from a broader set of investors, and continue to advance their pipelines and mature their platforms. Sometimes drugs emerge quickly, and sometimes it takes longer, with pivots along the way, with IPO and M&A events as a part of those journeys. Sometimes failure happens, and we try to find value out of the ashes (via reverse mergers, for instance). But bringing drugs to patients is the ultimate goal and long-term correlate for value creation – and it’s financed by all the phases of this capital market continuum from seed round to public follow-on financing.

To dive more deeply, here are seven observations around topics that are often misunderstood (or forgotten) about biotech IPOs today.

Caveat emptor. If you don’t like it when early stage biotech companies access public equity capital, then don’t participate in the offering. No one is ever forced to buy an IPO, and we generally don’t allocate much of the book to retail investors or fair-weather flaky funds. When I hear folks complaining about IPOs being “too early”, I just think about that fundamental rule of investing: caveat emptor. The buyer takes the risk. If you don’t want to buy into new offerings, you don’t have to. Rather than complaining that you got burned, don’t buy them. We generally participate in all of our portfolio’s private rounds and initial public offerings, as do most venture firms. The market for biotech IPOs over the past few years has only included willing participants, who were comfortable with the risk-return profile of the offering when they participated.

Drug timelines and risks aren’t linear with “R&D stage”. A frequent criticism of preclinical IPOs is that they are too far from the market and too risky. The reality is an Alzheimer’s project initiating a Phase 2a is likely farther from the market, and more risky, than many preclinical orphan disease plays (e.g., Agios and Blueprint took orphan cancer drugs from preclinical to registration in ~4 years). Serial entrepreneur Mike Gilman made a similar reflection in a pair of outstanding blogs on risk: arguing, for instance, an early stage oligo for SMA may be far less risky, and faster to market, than a mid-clinic rheumatoid arthritis drug (here, here). Understanding the nuances between different development paths with regard to risk, cost, and time helps underscore why generalizations are often wrong about preclinical or early stage stories.

Being public is hard, especially as an early stage company. Advancing a preclinical or early clinical company under the bright lights of the public markets isn’t easy. Public investors aren’t very patient at times, and every day volatility in the markets is a gut-wrenching rollercoaster. Many public investors also aren’t long term investor-builders; they’re traders looking to make quick returns, not to help make a drug. Working on the conversion of platforms into products in the public markets is challenging, and we know that going into the IPO process. The cold light of disclosure in the markets for preclinical companies means that important animal studies are material releases; that’s a tough place to be when you are working out the kinks, given how nasty the public market reactions can be. It’s also expensive to be public, with fees to lawyers and auditors, bigger finance and compliance teams, etc. And then there’s the “relevancy challenge” I’ve talked about before – staying top of mind for the 40 or so key institutional investors. So for those critical of “too many IPOs” I can assure you that no credible management team or Board thinks, “let’s go public because it will be fun and easy” – it’s not.

Instead, companies fundamentally go public to access bigger institutional pools of capital that aren’t available to private startups. If you want to scale your business, you need to access that bigger pool of capital. Over the course of biotech history, many great companies accessed the public markets as preclinical stories in order to raise more capital: Gilead and Regeneron in the early 1990s, Alnylam in early 2000s, and Agios, Blueprint, Intellia, Crisper in 2013-2016, to name only a few.

Anyone who has raised private rounds knows that the fundraising process is an arduous months-long proctology exam that ends in the issuance of senior preferred securities with special rights and privileges, including both debt-like and equity features, which is very different from the typical and straightforward common stock in public offerings. By going public, a biotech can access these larger and “cleaner” equity markets, which are essential to building and scaling R&D-intensive businesses over time.

Building biotech’s is a long-term journey, and having public investors as partners is therefore critical. Venture creation firms, as well as later stage VCs who focus on the midgame of emerging private investing, are important early in the life of a company, but don’t have the capital or decadal timeframes to advance R&D from discovery idea through to the market all by ourselves. We need public investors as partners to continue this journey together, and many of these players participate with us by crossing over into pre-IPO private rounds – enabling a smooth transition into the public markets. Thankfully, there are enough deep-pocketed, long-term public equity specialists in our field to work with us as we build and grow these biotech firms. Sure, having the big long-only “generalist” funds engaged in biotech is important in the long-run, and they’ve been out recently with the “risk-off” environment, but the reality is they have sat on their hands at prior pullbacks in the market too. And day-trader retail investors, who may be helpful for day-to-day liquidity, are not really the deep-pocketed company-building partners a biotech needs in the long run. It’s worth nothing that any VCs who constantly throw junk at these important downstream public equity partners aren’t likely to be in the business over multiple cycles.