d41586-023-00978-2_25210132.png

Demand for lithium is soaring. The element is a crucial ingredient in green technologies, including batteries in phones, laptops, electric cars and electricity grids1,2. Lithium ion batteries are among the best options for holding charge and delivering power efficiently. By 2025, demand for elemental lithium is set to be three times higher (150,000–190,000 tonnes) than it was in 20183. And by 2100, that could rise to 400,000–700,000 tonnes per year4.

In theory, there is enough lithium in the ground to meet that need — roughly 20 million tonnes (Mt) are available in reserves where the element is economic to extract, and nearly 90 Mt more resources have been identified elsewhere5. But, in practice, there is a production bottleneck. It is slow and expensive to open new mines and processing facilities, so demand could outstrip supply in the next decade (see ‘Lithium supply gap’). The International Energy Agency (IEA) predicts that, by 2030, producers will be able to deliver only half of the lithium industry’s needs while meeting sustainability targets that are in line with the Paris climate agreement6.

Source: IEA

The methods used to mine and process lithium from rocks, brines and clays are also not up to scratch. They have changed little over the past century, and rely on mechanical and chemical processes that are inefficient, wasteful and damaging to the environment. The whole basis of lithium mining and processing needs to be rethought.

Conventionally, rocky ores are roasted at 1,100 °C and then baked in acid at 250 °C to liberate (‘leach’) lithium in its sulfate form (Li2SO4)7. A similar procedure is used for clays8. Next, undesired metals are separated out using half a dozen chemical reactions, which require more heat and reagents. Finally, the solution is evaporated to leave pure lithium carbonate (Li2CO3) or lithium hydroxide (LiOH). Brines are treated similarly, or can be left outside to evaporate for months to a year — a rate that is too slow to boost the industry.

Chemical processing of lithium also consumes a lot of energy and water: producing 1 tonne of lithium salts requires roughly as much electricity as six US homes use in a year (60 megawatt hours), as well as a small swimming pool’s worth of water (70 cubic metres). It generates a lot of solid waste9 and emissions. Depending on the feedstock, producing 1 tonne of Li2CO3 or LiOH releases between 3 and 17 tonnes of carbon dioxide — 2 to 11 times that for 1 tonne of steel, and more than a round-trip flight for one passenger from San Francisco to New York City (roughly 1.5 tonnes of CO2). All told, processing accounts for about 70% of CO2 emissions associated with lithium production6; mining and transport are responsible for the rest (see ‘Emissions from lithium extraction’). By our calculations using IEA data, this totalled 3.6 million tonnes of CO2 in 2020 for Li2CO3. By 2050, the IEA data suggest those emissions could grow to 60 million tonnes of CO2 per year.

Source: IEA

Expansion of mining also has a lot of downsides. Most of the world’s lithium comes from a few remote regions5. More than half (54%) is mined in Western Australia from hard rock ‘spodumene’ ores. Brines are the next most common source, found in surface pools and geothermal springs in the salt flats (salars) of the ‘lithium triangle’ between Chile, Bolivia and Argentina, and in California. Lithium-bearing clays have also been identified across the Mojave Desert in southern California, southern Nevada, Mexico, Serbia and Tanzania.

These predominantly dry regions already experience water stress, which is compounded by climate risks, including extreme heat and flooding. Floods can spread pollution to nearby water bodies. For instance, debris or ‘gangue’ left in evaporation ponds contains heavy metals, such as arsenic, thallium and chromium, as well as uranium and thorium, naturally occurring radioactive elements that are also present in lithium ores.

The adverse social consequences of mining range from inadequate safety and health protections to human-rights violations. It will be essential for lithium-mining companies to uphold the strong environmental, social and governance commitments many have made to continue to protect the environment and the health of workers and local residents (see, for example, go.nature.com/3k3qfbb).

If nothing changes, simply ramping up lithium production at existing sites could negate the benefits of the clean technologies they power. Here, we highlight six priorities for the lithium industry.

Extract lithium in fewer steps

Direct extraction of lithium from brines or acidic solutions avoids the need for many chemical reactions and consumes less raw material, water and energy. Chemists and engineers are piloting such systems, although most have yet to be commercialized. These use a ‘sorbent’ — often a porous metal oxide — to attract and concentrate lithium ions in a column10. The ions are flushed out using hydrochloric or sulfuric acid (H2SO4), and the sorbent can then be reused.

Electrolysis is another way to save on reagents and emissions. Conventionally, Li2SO4 solution is converted into battery-grade lithium salts by reacting it with sodium carbonate (Na2CO3) to make Li2CO3 and then with calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH)2) to form LiOH. But both reactants are carbon intensive to produce. Passing an electric current through the solution instead produces reactions at the electrodes. At the positive electrode, water is converted into protons (H+) and oxygen (O2), and at the negative electrode, water turns into hydroxide (OH) and hydrogen (H2). Li+ ions migrate to the negative electrode, where they combine with hydroxide ions to make LiOH. The protons made at the positive electrode then combine with the leftover sulfate (SO42−) to create H2SO4, which can be recovered.

These processes still need to be optimized. Chemists should design sorbents that can take up lithium selectively, quickly and effectively while not deteriorating; those available today are unable to combine these qualities. In electrolysis, electrode materials need be more sustainable, affordable and stable at high temperatures. For example, some elements that are used to coat electrodes, such as iridium, degrade above 50 °C and should be avoided. Different designs, sizes and geometries of electrodes and reactors need to be explored.

Convert waste into valuable commodities