41893_2023_1241_Fig1_HTML.png

Abstract

Efforts to make food systems more sustainable have emphasized reducing adverse environmental impacts of agriculture. In contrast, chemical and biological processes that could produce food without agriculture have received comparatively little attention or resources. Although there is a possibility that someday a wide array of attractive foods could be produced chemosynthetically, here we show that dietary fats could be synthesized with <0.8 g CO2-eq kcal−1, which is much less than the >1.5 g CO2-eq kcal−1 now emitted to produce palm oil in Brazil or Indonesia. Although scaling up such synthesis could disrupt agricultural economies and depend on consumer acceptance, the enormous potential reductions in greenhouse gas emissions as well as in land and water use represent a realistic possibility for mitigating the environmental footprint of agriculture over the coming decade.

Main

The prodigious quantities of food produced by global agriculture entail correspondingly vast areas of land unavailable to natural ecosystems1,2,3, water resources used and polluted4,5, and greenhouse gases (GHGs) emitted to the atmosphere3,6. Efforts to reduce such impacts despite the world’s growing and ever-richer population have focused on limiting demand for the most resource- and pollution-intensive foods7, decreasing the inputs to (and thereby impacts of) agricultural production8 and using produced food more efficiently9,10. Here we highlight another possibility: producing food without agriculture.

An increasing number of academic studies and for-profit ventures have recently demonstrated that edible molecules can be synthesized via chemical and biological processes without need of agricultural feedstocks. Whereas plant-, cell- or fungi-based proteins and meat substitutes made from processed agricultural commodities are increasingly available, synthetically produced food may contain carbon from fossil fuels, waste or the atmosphere—that is, feedstocks that are not the product of agricultural photosynthesis. Futuristic as this may sound, the idea of such non-agricultural food is not novel. Amid the food shortages of World War II, German chemists successfully synthesized a coal-based margarine that was consumed by German citizens and troops11,12. After the war, a German company began synthesizing the amino acid methionine in industrial quantities, initially for treating malnutrition and later as an additive to animal feed13. In the 1960s and 1970s, US chemist Archibald McPherson proposed synthetic food in response to neo-Malthusian population projections, including in a letter published in the journal Nature14,15. Yet the prospects for producing food in this way raises many questions, prominent among them: what kind of food might feasibly be synthesized and with what advantages over agricultural products?

Here we introduce the range of options for producing food without agricultural inputs and then analyse with greater specificity the potential for synthesizing dietary fats. Details of our analytic approach are given in Methods. In summary, we estimate and compare lifecycle energy use by, and GHG emissions from, fats produced by conventional agriculture with molecularly identical fats produced by chemical synthesis, in each case across a range of land-use and energy scenarios. We use estimates of emissions and land use from recent literature, and we convert non-CO2 to CO2-eq GHG using 100-yr global warming potentials, including legacy land-use-change emissions.

Results

Figure 1 summarizes several potential pathways for synthesizing fats, proteins and carbohydrates from different carbon feedstocks, indicating the current scales of each process by the weight of arrows. Syngas (a mixture of H2 and CO) and ethylene (C2H4) are now produced from fossil fuels and organic wastes at a scale of >1 Mt yr−1 (via gasification and steam cracking, respectively)16. Such syngas and ethylene may then be converted by processes such as Ziegler or Fischer-Tropsch to paraffins, fatty acids and fats17; by processes such as Strecker to amino acids and then proteins18; or by electrochemical catalysis and processes such as the Formose reaction to methanol and then carbohydrates19. Each of these pathways has been successfully demonstrated, although most occur today at relatively small scales (with the important exception of the amino acid methionine, ~1.4 Mt of which was synthesized industrially in 2020 (ref. 13)). Biological pathways to fats, proteins and carbohydrates also exist. Bioenzymatic catalysis has produced carbohydrates from atmospheric carbon20, and all macronutrients have been produced from atmospheric carbon via fermentation of electrosynthetic intermediates, including hydrogen18 and acetate21. Fats and proteins have also been produced from fossil carbon via methanotrophs and oleotrophs22,23,24,25.

Fig. 1: Schematic of potential pathways to synthesize food without agriculture.

Proteins, fats and carbohydrates can be synthesized from a range of carbon feedstocks via multiple chemical and biological pathways (arrows). The weight and colour of the arrows indicate the scale at which the different processes have been demonstrated and the energy required per mass unit output, respectively (see Supplementary Fig. 1 and Supplementary Table 1 for references). Dashed lines indicate where energy requirements remain highly uncertain. Circular labels on each arrow further indicate whether the process is typically continuous (C) or batched (B). NH3 is ammonia, H2 is hydrogen gas, MeOH is methanol and AcO- is acetate. In the context of this study, we exclude agriculturally produced carbon feedstocks.

Although biological and chemical pathways appear intermixed in Fig. 1, chirality is in fact a clear dividing line between them. Chemical pathways can access more economical regimes of temperature, pressure, rate constant and equilibrium constant but can struggle to distinguish between left-handed (l) and right-handed (d) molecular forms. A perfect synthesis of glucose (four chiral centres) with no enantioselectivity would produce an edible compound only 1/16th of the time. By contrast, bioenzymatic techniques offer exquisite mechanisms for installing position-specific functional groups but can operate only in the limited range of process conditions in which life exists—mild temperatures and aqueous environments in which not all feedstocks are soluble. The result is a sharp distinction in Fig. 1: chemical techniques prevail for the synthesis of fats (generally achiral) and the amino acids glycine, which is achiral, and methionine, which is digestible in both the l- and d- forms. Bioenzymatic techniques predominate for the synthesis of all other amino acids (at least one chiral centre) and all carbohydrates (many chiral centres)13.

Among these various pathways, we focus on fats in particular because: (1) they are among the simplest nutrients to synthesize thermochemically (that is, achiral and simply structured, compatible with large-scale soap-making and polymer chemistry techniques), (2) they are the only macronutrient successfully synthesized at scale in the past (although not today26), (3) they serve as gustatorily undifferentiated ‘baseload calories’ in many foods and (4) oilcrops such as soy and palm have an enormous environmental footprint globally (for example, >300 Mha or ~7% of agricultural land and 2.89 Gt CO2-eq or ~20% of annual greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture and land-use change in recent years3). Here we focus on land use and GHG emissions, but we recognize that there are many other factors relevant to the sustainability of food production systems.

Depending on the source and quantity of energy used and associated land-use emissions (for example, N2O from fertilizer or CO2 from clearing land), the GHG emissions per kilocalorie of fats produced by agricultural systems range from <1.0 g CO2-eq kcal−1 (for example, soybeans grown in the United States and Europe) to >3 g CO2-eq kcal−1 (for example, palm oil grown in Africa; Fig. 2a). These regional differences reflect differences in the rates of land-use change, the carbon density of cleared land and farming practices. For land-efficient crops, such as oil palm, patterns of land-use change drive differences in emissions intensity; yields and farming practices largely explain variations in emissions among more land-intensive crops such as soybeans (Fig. 2a). In comparison, we estimate that analogous fats synthesized from natural gas feedstock using energy with the carbon intensity of the current average of US electricity would produce ~0.8 g CO2-eq kcal−1, and with near zero emissions if using carbon captured from the air and relying exclusively on non-emitting sources of energy (Fig. 2b). This is considerably less than the >1.5 g CO2-eq kcal−1 of soy grown in Brazil or palm oil grown in Brazil or Indonesia (Fig. 2a). The only case identified where the emissions intensity of synthetic palm oil approaches the current emissions of oilcrops from sub-Saharan Africa (that is, >3 g CO2-eq kcal−1) is the case in which high-carbon intensity energy (for example, coal) is used to reduce a CO2 feedstock and incorporate the resulting carbon into synthetic fats (that is, the lower right corner of Fig. 2b). The contours in Fig. 2b illustrate an important distinction between synthetic fats produced from feedstocks containing internal energy, such as CH4, and those without, such as CO2: in the latter case (corresponding to the bottom half of Fig. 2b), the emissions intensity of the synthetic fats has a very strong dependence on the emissions intensity of the sourced electricity, while emissions for fossil-derived synthetic fats (corresponding to the top half of Fig. 2b) are dominated by the feedstock source. These trends reflect the fact that the energy required to capture and reduce the CO2 feedstock into hydrocarbons is about eight times greater than the energy needed to convert hydrocarbons into synthetic fats. We also estimate that the land area required per kilocalorie of synthetic fat produced would be an order of magnitude smaller than that of agricultural fats: 15–20 million kcal of agricultural fats per hectare per year3 as compared with >1 billion kcal of synthetic fats per hectare per year (see Supplementary Information 1.3 and Supplementary Table 5).